Header image

Corrupting a Nation

Posted by Natalie in Society - 29 February 2012

Or why the NHS bill will make us all poorer in every way

At 27 I didn’t consider myself innocent. Then I left the UK and moved to Germany, and lost something that up until that point I didn’t even know I had. From birth, unquestioning access to free healthcare had instilled in me a sense of worth, value, happiness and security.

In Germany, where the system is an expensive and complex minefield of private and ‘public’ insurance, and where unequivocal advice is frustratingly hard to come by, my NHS security blanket was gone and the game commenced. The wrangling with insurance companies, the fear of going to the doctor in case (s)he diagnosed something I wasn’t covered for, the way they make you jump through hoops like you have to prove entitlement to a treatment that could ultimately save your life. The game in which preexisting medical conditions are shameful aspects of the past to be suppressed like dark secrets. Luckily, the doctors in Germany are more than happy to ‘misdiagnose’ – in other words, you can tell them what you’re covered for and what not, and they’ll write up your medical report accordingly.

In a country famed for transparency, it seems that some of the most respected members of society are corrupted by a system in which access to healthcare is far from equal. Visit the doctor with a private insurance policy and you’ll be seen immediately. The doctor is also likely to refer you to another specialist for another treatment or consultation – they keep you in an expensive loop, passing around patients whose insurance policies will pay out. Those with less cover wait longer and experience far fewer referrals, and in this chaotic mess where financial interests are inextricably linked to individuals’ well-being, it’s impossible to know which treatments are essential and which are frivolous.

I’ll admit I cried a lot at first. To think that there are people out there whose job it is to price up my life, that it can be valued like a commodity. I’d never truly comprehended the value of the NHS not only to my well-being, but also to my sense of it. Leaving the UK stripped me of a naivety I never knew I had, and though the depression lifted, there’s no going back: a bitter cynicism endures.

We already know that the NHS bill is undemocratic. We know that most health professionals oppose it. We know that it will create unequal access to healthcare. We know that it will be wide open to corruption and line the pockets of the already rich and powerful. We know it will allow the Tories that vacuous but apparently essential victory of finally assigning a financial value to everything, abstract and concrete (the environment’s next). We know all this.

The worst thing though, is that it will corrupt the people. Put a price on our kidneys, Mr. Cameron, on our lungs, our livers, our hearts, and what becomes of your Big Society? Strip away the last shreds of our incredulity, and the result will be a malady that no amount of money can cure.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 You can leave a response, or trackback.

2 Responses

  • greatruaha says:

    Interesting article about a topic that has caused me a lot of distress in the past. Glad to say it has all been sorted, or so it seems, but it took a long time to feel at ease living outside the NHS in Germany.

    People who complain about the NHS have no idea what it is like to have to live without it and need to see a doctor.

  • John says:

    Natalie, by comparing your experience in Germany to the UK, this post hit me like a sledge hammer between the eyes. Very scary!
    As for the environment, organisations like WWF have been doing just that. In fact putting a financial figure on the “free” life support system shows the economic stupidity of many of the things done for financial profit as when the damage to the eco-system is included they clearly cost us all dearly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>